An option is a right, but not an obligation, to buy or sell a property, a stake or rights on set terms in the future. Options are everywhere in real estate deals: the right to buy a plot once permits are granted, the right to buy a building back from an investor, a partner's right to exit a joint venture at a pre-agreed price. An option lets you lock in a deal now and decide later, once it is clear whether the project works. Below we explain the types of options, how they are documented in Russia and Europe, and where their weak points are.
Law as of November 2026. There are no public statistics on options in real estate deals. This overview is not a substitute for legal due diligence on a specific deal.
What an option is
An option has two sides. One gets a right; the other takes on the obligation to complete the deal if the right is exercised. The right is usually paid for with an option premium.
Calls and puts
- Call: the right to buy
The holder can require the property or stake to be sold to it at the agreed price. For example, a developer gets the right to buy a plot once a building permit is issued.
- Put: the right to sell
The holder can require the other side to buy the property or stake. For example, an investor in a joint venture gets the right to sell its stake to the partner after five years.
- Buy-back right
A form of call: a tenant or former owner can buy the building. Russian law expressly allows the buy-out of leased property (Civil Code art. 624).
- Right of first refusal
Not strictly an option: if the owner decides to sell, it must first offer the property to the right holder on the same terms.
Options under Russian law
- Option to conclude a contract (Civil Code art. 429.2)
- An irrevocable offer: one party offers in advance to conclude a contract, for example the sale of a building, and the other may accept within the term. Acceptance concludes the contract. If no term is set, it is one year.
- Option contract (Civil Code art. 429.3)
- A contract under which one party may demand performance, for example the transfer of a stake, within the term. If no demand is made, the obligation lapses.
- Option premium
- Payment for the right itself. It is not refunded if the right is not exercised, unless the parties agree otherwise.
- Essential terms
- The option must allow the subject and other essential terms of the future contract to be determined. For real estate that means a precise description of the property and the price or a price formula.
- Option inside another agreement
- An option can be built into another agreement: a lease, a joint venture agreement or a corporate agreement (Civil Code art. 67.2).
Deals in Russian LLC stakes are notarised (Law 14-FZ art. 21), so options over stakes in a project company are in practice also documented before a notary.
Where options are used in real estate
An option is useful when a deal should be locked in but only makes sense to complete under a condition: a permit is granted, a building is finished, a return is reached.
Typical deals
A developer pays the owner a premium for the right to buy a plot at an agreed price within a term, while it prepares plans and obtains permits. If the project fails, the developer loses only the premium.
Partners agree who buys out whom and at what price: on an investor's exit, on deadlock, on breach. Calls and puts over stakes are the backbone of a joint venture exit.
The seller of a building gets the right to buy it back at the end of the lease. The price is best set by formula; otherwise the buy-back is at market value on the date.
Rights to renew, expand or buy the premises. Russian law gives tenants a pre-emptive right to a new lease term (Civil Code art. 621), but renewal terms are better written down.
An investor gets the right to buy the finished building from the developer at a price based on future rent. The developer gets a clear buyer and finds it easier to borrow.
A developer gets the right to buy the neighbouring plot for a second phase if the first one sells.
Example: an option on a plot
A ₽1bn plot, 18-month option
- Option premium
- ₽30m
- Developer buys the plot
- ₽1bn
- Total cost to the developer
- ₽1.03bn
- Option premium
- ₽30m
- Developer does not buy
- ₽0
- Developer's loss
- ₽30m
Illustrative example; it does not describe a specific deal. The premium is an assumption. The landowner keeps the premium either way, and the developer pays the full price only when the project can go ahead.
Russia and Europe
Real estate options exist in almost every European country, but the form and the holder's protection differ.
Comparison
| Form | Holder's protection | |
|---|---|---|
| Russia | Option to conclude a contract or option contract (Civil Code arts. 429.2, 429.3), often inside a corporate agreement | The option is not shown in the real estate register. Protection is contractual: penalties, security deposit, pledge, ban on disposal |
| United Kingdom | Option agreement: a developer gets the right to buy land once planning permission is granted, usually at a discount to market value | The option is registered at the Land Registry and binds a new owner |
| Spain | Opción de compra: the right to buy a property within a term at an agreed price | The option can be entered in the Property Registry, and then binds third parties |
| Germany | Ankaufsrecht: the right to buy land | A contract over land requires notarial form (BGB §311b). The right is protected by a priority notice in the land register |
Risks
In Russia an option to buy a building is not registered. If the owner sells to someone else, the holder is left with a damages claim, not the property. Pledges, deposits and bans on disposal are needed.
If the price is "market value on exercise" without a valuation procedure, the parties will argue. A formula is safer: a fixed price with indexation, or a cap rate applied to actual rent.
An option tied to an event, such as a permit, must define the event and the term precisely. Otherwise it is unclear when the right can be used and when it has expired.
If the party obliged to sell goes bankrupt, the administrator may challenge the option or disclaim an unfavourable contract. The protection is the same: security and early exercise.
The premium is income for the grantor, and the exercise price must be at market for tax purposes, especially between related parties.
Summary
In short: when an option makes sense and what to check in it.
- What it is
A right to buy or sell in the future on terms agreed now, paid for with a premium.
- When it fits
The deal only makes sense on a condition: a permit, completion, a return, a partner's exit.
- Form in Russia
Civil Code arts. 429.2 and 429.3; options over stakes sit in corporate agreements and go through a notary.
- What to check
Description of the property, price or formula, term, trigger event, security and what happens to the premium.
- Weak point
In Russia the option is not visible in the register, so the holder needs contractual protection against a sale to a third party.
Questions and answers
How does an option differ from a preliminary contract?
A preliminary contract obliges both parties to sign the main contract. An option obliges only one side: the other decides whether to use the right.
Is the premium refunded if the option is not exercised?
No, unless the option says otherwise. The premium pays the grantor for holding the property for the holder all that time.
Can an option be transferred?
Yes, unless the option prohibits assignment. A developer can pass its right over a plot to a project company or a new partner.
Is a notary needed?
For an option over an LLC stake, in practice yes. For an option to buy a building from a company, notarial form is generally not required.
What if the seller refuses to perform?
If the offer has been accepted, the contract is concluded and the holder can ask a court to register the transfer (Civil Code art. 551) while the seller still owns the property. If it has been sold to someone else, damages and penalties remain.
Sources
- Russian Civil Code: art. 429.2 (option to conclude a contract), art. 429.3 (option contract), art. 67.2 (corporate agreement), art. 551 (registration of transfer), arts. 621 and 624 (lease renewal and buy-out)
- Federal Law No. 42-FZ of 08.03.2015 amending Part One of the Russian Civil Code
- Federal Law No. 14-FZ of 08.02.1998 «On limited liability companies»: art. 21
- Supreme Court of Russia Plenum ruling No. 49 of 25.12.2018 on the conclusion and interpretation of contracts
- Spain: Reglamento Hipotecario, art. 14 (registration of a purchase option)
- Germany: Civil Code (BGB), §311b (notarial form for land contracts)